So I heard about this new apple…

You probably have heard about Cosmic Crisp.  It is a new variety of apple that will soon be popping up in just about every major grocery store.  At its launch this winter it will ship millions of bushels, and be supported by millions of dollars of advertising.  You will be told that it is an improvement on its parent: Honeycrisp.

What you won’t be told is that your local orchard can’t grow it.

Not because it won’t grow in this climate, and not because we wouldn’t like to plant it.  The reason we can’t grow it here is that we are legally prevented from planting it.  Cosmic Crisp was developed in Washington State, and the fruit growers there have maintained exclusive rights to plant and market Cosmic Crisp.  No one outside the state is allowed to grow it.

This is just the latest example of a trend that has been developing over the last decade.  You’ve probably heard of Jazz, Kiku, SweeTango, Opal, SnapDragon, or Evercrisp, There are about 30 varieties of apples now that are not freely available for growers to plant.  They are protected by “clubs”, patents, marketing arrangements, and other methods designed by lawyers to maintain close ownership of the varieties.  As a mid-Atlantic grower, I can buy my way into some of these arrangements if I like, but other clubs are completely closed to me: like Cosmic Crisp.  (There is a great article from NPR on this topic here.  The situation has only worsened since it was written.)

This close control is intended to ensure quality, limit supply, provide funds for investment in development and marketing, and to provide an aura of exclusivity.  But it carries an incredible risk for growers, because of this I am certain: there is not enough shelf space at the grocery to carry all of these varieties, and all of those varieties will be competing against each other.

The number one risk in growing apples is not weather, not disease, not insects, and not labor.  The number one long-term risk for apples is price collapse because of lack of demand for the variety.  The timeline for apple maturity is so long, the capital establishment expense so high, and the variable cost of production so great that only a high price for a high yield over a long period will justify the planting.  Yields and longevity can be managed, but wholesale prices cannot.

Ironically, the apple suffering the most from this onslaught of new varieties provides a template for how growers should be approaching the future.  Red Delicious became popular not because it was the best tasting variety, but because a critical mass of growers in the Northeast got together and decided that the hundreds (literally) of varieties that they were trying to sell could not possibly be managed in the marketplace.  Red Delicious was pretty, grew well across climates, and tasted good enough that everybody could make money on it as long as they stuck together.

It won’t take long for everyone (except Washington State) to realize this impending cliff, and the Red Delicious-inspired solution.  I suspect that sometime in the near future, the walls will come tumbling down as the marketing czars realize that they don’t have the critical mass to compete with Washington State, which produces most of the apples sold in the US.  The supply-side market will determine which new varieties will win.  And growers stuck with the wrong varieties may very well end up broke.

As for me, I will grow a few of these new varieties when I can.  They ALL taste great, and will be a welcome addition in our farm market to compliment some of the old varieties that continue to stand up well: like Cameo, Stayman, Jonagold, and Macoun.

Just don’t expect to see any Cosmic Crisp.


Where do those beautiful tomatoes come from?

Sometimes I have to admit my limitations.  Not often, but sometimes.

Tomatoes are one of the crops I’ve considered growing.  The local auction prices for tomatoes often far exceed the cost of tree fruit.  It bothers me that something planted as a seed in the spring can be worth more than the fruit of a tree that needs to be tended its entire life.  So it sometimes seems like easy money to grow tomatoes.

Except that we buy our tomatoes from Daniel Lapp.

Daniel is an Amish neighbor.  He grows the most beautiful tomatoes around, and uses the proceeds to help support his large family.  They don’t deliver the tomatoes for us, but secretly we all enjoy the trip over to Daniel’s house to pick them up.  Driving past the well-tended gardens and farm buildings, the children always greet us with bare feet and a smile, and quickly and efficiently sort the tomatoes and load the car for us.  All transactions are cash.  Our prices are largely fixed through the season despite volatile auction prices, and we have never had a disagreement with him.

I could not grown a better tomato myself, and why should I try?  Daniel makes an honest living from growing food.  Just like I try to do.  I’m happy to help support him and his family.

So the next time you buy a Shaw tomato, please know that it is not a Shaw tomato.  It is a Lapp tomato, and you are helping to support a good family.

A slow start

Fruit Growers are fond of saying “Every year is different.”  And there is some truth to that.  Like last year, March was significantly cooler than February, which is highly unusual.  The mean temperature on our farm was actually 4 degrees LOWER in March than February.  But April has also been well below normal.  Many years, we are deep into the bloom season by now, but this year, the only growth on the trees occurred last week when we had 3 days that were nearly 20 degrees above normal.  The apple trees took the opportunity to grow an amazing 1.5″ of leaves in just two days.

And now the trees are shivering with expected lows below freezing.  The apricots have already bloomed, the plums are just past peak, and some varieties of peaches are blooming.  So a freeze tonight will likely take some of the fruit, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing since we spend a lot of time thinning extra fruit anyway.

Strawberries are running way behind schedule.  It seems likely to me that we will miss our usual Memorial Day opening this year.  In fact, based on the short term forecast, we might not be open by the weekend after that.

Whatever happens, we’ll deal with it.  But normal would be nice for a change.

Pick your own DO’s and DON’T’s

We do a lot of business with pick-your-own.  In fact, it has become the core of our retail offerings.  To help you get the most out of your experience, here are a few tips:

DO:  Come prepared.  You probably don’t need hip boots in our well manicured fields.  But high heels are not a good idea (don’t laugh, we see it pretty often).  A hat is also a good idea for berry picking.  Sunscreen is advisable.

Beautiful cherries from 2015

DO:  Come early in the day.  Several reasons:  1) it gets hot in the afternoon; 2) the morning light gets under the vegetation (on the eastern side) to make it easy to see; 3) you’ll beat the crowds and have easier picking.

DON’T:  Stop at the first sight of fruit.  Chances are good, everybody else stopped there too and already picked the good stuff.  Spend a few minutes wandering around so you know if you are in a good spot.

DO:  Try a bite.  Yes, you technically should wash your food before you eat it; but we never use any chemicals within the designated “pre-harvest interval.”  Which means you don’t need to worry about residues.  And since the BIGGEST factor in a fruit’s flavor is its degree of ripeness, you’ll want to learn quickly how to know by sight how ripe the fruit is.  And the best way to learn is trial and error.  In short, we want you to harvest the fruit you think tastes best.

DON’T:  Eat all our profits without paying for them.  As we say, “sampling is encouraged, gluttony is theft.”  You wouldn’t eat your way through the local grocery store would you?  Why would you do it to your local farmer?  Seriously, we ask these kind of customers to leave.

DO and DON’T:  Enjoy your stay, but don’t stay all day.  This is tricky for us: we are an authentic family farm with wide open spaces and a laid-back approach to crowd control.  But if everyone spread a picnic blanket under every tree, it would be more like a city park than a farm.  We want to be a farm.  So you are welcome to have lunch at our picnic tables, and we want your kids to run and do cartwheels, but please be mindful that we are not a park.

DO:  Ask an employee for advice on the varieties, and the best places to pick.

DO: If picking a fruit that is sold by weight (not apples), feel free to bring a container if you like your container.  Or use the ones we have available.

Yep. We love our bees!

Farmers get a lot of bad press about their relationship with bees.  Some of that is deserved.  But don’t believe everything you read on Facebook.

We rely EXCLUSIVELY on native pollinators to turn pretty flowers into money making fruit every spring.  You may be surprised to know that the majority of this work is done by bees and insects other than the honeybee.  Bumble bees, sweat bees, Japanese orchard bees… the list goes on.  They all live within flying distance of our orchards, and in many cases live within several hundred yards of the orchards.

We manage this in several ways.  First, we provide habitat for these bees.  Most of our orchards are within sight of woods and creek beds where many native pollinators like to nest.  We also frequently provide pollinator friendly cover crops or wildflowers where they can store up energy when our orchards or bushes aren’t blooming.  (See the video on cover crops here.)

Secondly, we try really hard not to hurt our pollinators by spraying the wrong chemical at the wrong time.  Our climate forces us to manage a multitude of pests by spraying insecticides.  In the old days, we would use an insecticide that killed most insects.  Today’s integrated pest management approach uses a more targeted method to spray a narrow spectrum insecticide for just the pest that is there.

Here is where the social media knowledge gap lies.  Neonicitoid insecticides are systemic in the plant to eliminate insects that are sucking or chewing on the trees.  Since bees and predator insects don’t eat our trees, they don’t get killed, even if they visit the orchard after a spray.  Moreover, in most commercial orchards, their exposure is very low because we don’t use this kind of systemic chemical until after the bloom is done.  So they aren’t getting exposed through the pollen.

If neonics’ were taken off the market, we’d be forced to move back to classes of chemicals that are even more lethal to predators, and it would be a setback for the current balanced approach that we have to managing our insect populations.

Still wonder whether the bees are safe?  Here are some pictures of a swarm of honeybees in one of our peach trees.  Our friendly neighborhood bee keeper is using a vacuum device to move them into a holding box, and then into a hive.  Even though we rely on these guys for our pollination, they stand a better chance of setting up a new colony with his care.  But they are welcome to come back and visit!


Another unusual winter

Winter?  What winter?

So far this has been the least snowy winter we’ve ever had.  We’ve had less than 6″ of snow here all season.  But even worse than the dearth of snow has been the warm temperatures since January.  The average temperature has been well above normal, so much so that we’re seeing record dates for early blooming trees.

We heard our first spring peeper frogs on 2/28, an incredible week ahead of last years’ record.  Apricots started blooming yesterday a week ahead of their record from 2012 (the year that most of the orchards east of the Mississippi lost their crops because of the weather).  Plums are at a very delicate bud stage, but not yet blooming.  Cherries, peaches, and apples remain tight.

And tight is good, because the weather roller coaster is headed downhill fast.  It snowed last night, and low temperatures are forecasted to be in the teens for the next few nights.  A significant snow storm is on tap for next week.  The good news here is that the sudden cool weather may have arrived just in time to slow the rest of the trees.

Time will tell…


An orchard no more…

Change is constant in an orchard.  We grow many different fruits, and there is always change about us: a new planting, a different tree in bloom, another fruit to thin, a different fruit to harvest, winter pruning.  But just as each of these chores has its beginning, all of these chores eventually end.  It is a constant cycle of activity that repeats itself each year, until it ends.

And all things come to end.  This year my neighbors decided to end their fruit business.  At one time, they were the largest orchard in the area, probably the county.  But like almost all orchards, they have reduced acreage over the last few decades as wholesale profit margins have diminished,  labor becomes harder to find, and long-term sustainability becomes more uncertain.

As they stand at the edge of retirement, they look forward to more time, more freedom, and less responsibility.  Life is short, and the sudden death of a beloved farming neighbor has reminded all of us that, as my father says, “life is not a dress rehearsal.”

But I of all people know how difficult this process has been for them.  We fruit growers are long term planters.  After all, the life span of a tree in an orchard is about the same as a child in a home.  And sometimes, for better or worse, we make connections to our trees that can be almost as hard to break.

So I am saddened by the loss of an orchard.  Saddened that a family tradition like my own has ended; saddened that the horticultural assets of our industry, namely our trees, are so unprofitable that our fields may be worth more without the trees than with them; and saddened that it is not unlikely that I too may face the same day as my neighbor.

If that day comes, I hope I handle it with as much fortitude and certainty as he has exhibited.

For now, as the season closes, I am thankful to be done with the labor of the year, and am working on planting plans for future years.  It is the time of the year for me that new orchards are conceived, and those connections to the land become more deeply rooted.  For today, I’d prefer to focus on new beginnings.

Endings are just hard.



A memorable storm

One of the sayings here on the farm is that “no two days are ever the same.”   And that is true.  Every day presents its own challenges: something breaks, another chore rises to the top of the list, a new crop comes into season.  But the fact is, some days are more memorable than others.  Yesterday was one of those days.

Strawberries have a rhythm.  We grow strawberries in a type of culture called “matted row.”  The basic idea is that the berries are planted in the ground and we work like crazy to keep the weeds out of them (rather than covering them in plastic).  This requires a lot of discipline.  Immediately after the berries have completed their crop, we spray a herbicide that is just strong enough to kill many of the weeds, but not strong enough to kill the berries.  Then they must be mowed just a few days later.  Then they  must be tilled to narrow the rows and destroy any leftover weeds.  Then they must immediately get a treatment of premergent herbicide to prevent new weeds from growing.  But things can go wrong with the rhythm.

Our rototiller is rather old, and while tilling I realized that the results were going to be quite poor unless we upgraded the old blades.  So 10 days later, the machine was ready to use.  But in 10 days, the plants had developed fresh new leaves and were growing quickly.

The only problem here is that the chemicals used to prevent the weeds can also burn the new strawberry leaves…  unless it is immediately rinsed away.  Since we only have trickle irrigation, the only way to get the badly needed herbicide on the crop was to await a storm.  And to be right about it; because if the herbicide went on, but the rain didn’t come, the crop would be damaged.

So last night after work, I was anxiously watching the radar and noticed that a storm was tracking to the east of us, but was building in size.  I prepared the sprayer, measured the material, and waited.  The sky blackened, thunder rumbled, and I saddled up and sped for the field.

I was dry for five minutes before the wind began to howl and the rain began to pour.  It turned out to be quite a storm with two inches of rain and over 30 mph winds.  The rain came sideways in sheets as I pulled my hat down and squared my shoulders into the wind.  The crusty salt from my sweaty hat dissolved and streamed down my face in a briny flow.  I questioned the wisdom of riding a tractor on a hill in a thunderstorm, and thought about how few people were hit by lightning or killed by sharks…. and about how less likely such an end would be if people didn’t expose themselves to lightning or sharks.

In the end, the field was sprayed, the product stayed off the leaves and moved into the topsoil where it would bond to the ground and prevent late summer weeds.  Everything worked out well, except for the phone in my pocket that needed a day of drying before it could be coaxed back to life.

And I made a memory.

April Foolish Weather

One of the obvious challenges in farming is the weather.

Apricot bloom from 2013.

Apricot bloom from 2013.

As mentioned in previous posts, horticultural crops like tree and berry fruit, are very vulnerable to spring weather.  Warm weather in the late winter can trick the plants into an early growth pattern, which can setup the plants for disaster if the weather returns to a normal pattern later in the spring.

After a snowy and normal February, we have just experienced one of the warmest March’s on record.  Statewide in Pennsylvania, the average temperature was a blistering 6.3 degrees above normal for the entire month.  The average high temperature for the month was nearly 10 degrees above average.  Spring Peeper frogs started their chorus on March 6, nearly 4 weeks ahead of schedule, and apricots were blooming by March 22.  We are experiencing the second earliest season, next to only 2012.

In 2012, we were lucky enough to dodge a major freeze during bloom.  The Midwest (and Michigan in particular) was not so lucky, and they lost all of their fruit.  Prices surged that year as supplies were low.

This year, we may not be so lucky.  We have had several mornings near 30 this week, but worse, there are forecasts for 3 nights in the mid 20’s in the coming week.  Apples are not too far along yet, but peaches, cherries, plums, and apricots are vulnerable to anything below 28.

In most professions, a knowledge of future events would allow one to take evasive action, and perhaps even benefit from what is coming.  In this job, there is nothing that can be done.  There are a few natural products that can be sprayed on the trees to provide a degree or two of buffer, and some big growers in Michigan have invested in large wind machines that stir calm cold air on frosty nights.  But those techniques are not useful for the wind-driven blasts of cold air forecasted this week.  Neither is there a futures market where risk can be hedged.

There is only one backup plan: insurance.  Crop insurance is available for apples, peaches, and to a limited extent, cherries and strawberries.  It is very expensive, requiring an investment of a large portion of the profits, but it can help take the sting out of a total crop failure.

And these failures may become more frequent if scientists are right about the changing climate.  My data would seem to corroborate forecasted trends of increasing volatility.  The last several years have shown a consistent pattern of very wet, very warm, very cold, and at times very dry.  Rain events have been extreme with a very large proportion of last years’ precipitation falling in just 3 or 4 storms.  Or just consider that 80% of this winters’ snowfall occurred in just one storm that set the all-time record for snowfall.  In contrast, March had something like 30% of the normal precipitation for the month.

So here’s hoping for a little error in the forecast this week.  Because if the weather stays just a few degrees warmer, we might even benefit from the cold.  How?  Because peaches usually set many more fruit than we want on the trees, and require extensive thinning.  If nature does the thinning for us, we can save a little labor and improve the quality of the remaining fruit.   But…  I’d rather not have to worry about it so much.




The ups and downs of cherries

Beautiful cherries from 2015

Beautiful cherries from 2015

I was once asked by a customer why cherries are so expensive.

The answer is pretty simple: blame it on our East Coast weather.  The last three years are a perfect example.  In 2013 and 2014, tough winters and light freezes during bloom combined to shrink the crop to about 20-30% of what would be considered a full crop.  This year, the crop had a huge “set”; that is, there was a very large bloom and almost of all of the blossoms produced a fruit.  All of the cherry orchards were amazed by how many cherries they saw.  I considered it to be a double or even triple crop.

Then in May we saw no rain.  For about six weeks from bloom until very late May, we received about 1/10 of an inch of rain.  The trees were heavy with cherries that couldn’t size because the leaves weren’t powering the tree because the leaves couldn’t grow because there was just too much load on the tree for the amount of water they were receiving.  All the cherry growers were in a panic that their crops would be dime-sized.

The we had the wettest June in history.  Literally.  Baltimore broke a record, and Harrisburg recorded their 8th wettest June (and we had about 15% more rain than Harrisburg).  Moreover, the rain was continuous throughout the month with not a single observation of two dry consecutive days.  (I’m pretty sure about that – our weather station broke down with all the rain.)

If there is one thing cherries don’t like, besides hail, it is wet weather.  It was a huge challenge to keep them from splitting and rotting in the fields.  Like it or not, the only way to save a crop like this is to apply fungicides to prevent them from rotting in the trees.  Only the very best and safest fungicides can be used for this.  These are also some of the most expensive chemicals sold.  Retail price: $800/gallon.

Adding insult to injury, we’ve been trying to establish new cherry trees to replace our aging orchard.  Our biggest challenge has been trying to grow them in the presence of an ever-expanding deer herd.  We’ve tried scents, plastic bags, expensive repellants and nothing seems to work.  Deer love to browse on cherries and really nothing will stop them.  Many of my two-year-old trees look no larger than when they were planted and some have been killed by the damage.

For the most part, growers in the Northwest don’t have to worry about these problems.  They grow their cherries in a desert climate far from the woods, and irrigate them from the huge water projects and hydro-electric dams that were paid for with federal tax dollars.  Yes, they can produce quality cherries at a low cost.  But in the end, we were able to size our crop, keep most of them from splitting and rotting, and produced a great crop that was enjoyed by many of our neighbors and customers.

So I think it is worth the effort to grow cherries…  but don’t think for a minute that it is easy, or will be cheap.